Router Plane

Monday, April 29, 2024

Game Piece Holder – #2 Finish Turning Prototype & Different Feature Accents

With the outside of the bowl turned to its final shape it’s time to start on the inside.  This starts by taking the blank out of the lathe and flipping it end for end so the base is now at the headstock end.  I didn’t mention the scored line near the bottom before but that’s where the bottom of the bowl will be.

Marking the bowls ¼” wall thickness is next to give me a starting guide.  Also, a hole is drilled just short of the depth I need to hollow out to.  Since I had the Fostner bit already in the chuck that’s what got used.

Here the bowl is a bit over half turned.  The red arrow points to a pencil line partway down the inside of the bowl.  That’s my reference mark showing from there to the lip of the bowl is the correct thickness with everything on down too thick.  From here it’s removing material and checking the wall thickness along with the depth until done.

Once the interior of the bowl is turned to size it gets sanded then removed from the 4-jaw chuck and the jaws get changed out once again.  This time a set of Jumbo jaws get installed and the bowl gets mounted top edge in.  As the bowl’s walls are only ¼” thick the jaws get lightly tightened down to prevent the walls from being damaged.  To provide some stability the tail stock gets a live center brought up and a little pressure applied to hold the bowl in place.  Now I can clean up most of the base then cut the foot off.

Last is to finish turning and cleaning the base up.  Here on the top left is after the foot was cut off and on the top right is the finished base.  The bottom two images show different views of the bowl.

With an actual mid-size bowl done I measured its real volume which was 1 cup with the calculated volume of .953 cups, close enough for our purposes.   The drawing below shows the comparison between all three different sizes that I will be making.

With the woods selected, the prototype finished along with the overall shape and stepped sizes set it’s time to do some testing of the various types of feature accents we discussed.  Those include the following where each of the items are about ½” or so down from the top of the bowl:

  • A copper band around the bowl.
  • Six equally spaced round aluminum or brass dots inlayed into the wood.
  • Six equally spaced square walnut pegs set into the wood deep enough so that when the bowl is turned, they will be visible on the inside of the bowl.
  • A turquoise ban inlayed around the bowl.
  • A band of brass shavings inlayed around the bowl set in a clear epoxy.

 Two other possibilities also include a feature similar to what’s at the top but at about ¼” up from the bottom of the bowl.

  • A series of three grooves burned into the bowl at the top and one at the bottom.
  • A feature ring consisting of three thin wood layers with the top and bottom matching and a contrasting center layer.

Now there were some early tests that got quickly discarded for one reason or another.  One example was the idea to use lead free solder to fill either square or round holes.  The photo below shows that test.  One problem was that the melting point of the solder was pretty close to the burning point of the wood and it ended up charring the edge of the holes.  Also, there was enough surface tension in the molten metal that the square corners didn’t get filled. 

Making a decision on which features to use is next.  During our discussions one was a clear choice, that of the turquoise inlay probably in oak as a nod to where we live in the Southwest.  Beyond that it was pretty open so I started with four promising possibilities.  The copper band, brass and aluminum dots and square walnut pegs.  Taking some scrap oak a block was laminated up and turned to a cylinder using the same process as the cedar prototype giving me a blank canvas to work with.  At this point a major part of the testing was to see if I could actually make what I had designed.  The brass and aluminum inlay dots had me concerned because with the bowl walls a ¼” thick I really only had 1/8” depth to work with.  Laying out the dots was the first problem since they needed to be equally spaced with the mounting hole drilled perpendicular to the center of the cylinder.  In the end this is the setup I used to accomplish that.

Cutting the dots, fastening them securely in place then bringing them flush to the wood turned out to be challenging but doable.  Both the copper band and walnut square inlays were easier than I thought.  The photo below shows the results from this first bit of testing. 

In a video call with my son, we discussed which options might look the best with which woods.  Using photos of three different woods and some time with Photoshop, I put together these possibilities.  More discussion ended up with selecting the copper/walnut for sure.  The burned lines in maple are a strong contender with the square walnut inlay and aluminum dots rejected.

Next alternates for the oak and turquoise were discussed as there were three different color mixes available with a fourth option of contrasting layers thrown in for good measure.  The choice was the top right image. 

Besides the oak choices there were eight others for the maple and cherry.  Those are shown below along with the walnut and copper version we had selected.  The cherry bowl generated the most versions and we ended up with five different possibilities.

I am not going to bore you with the discussions on how the final designs were selected but here are the final four choices.  In a curious twist the aluminum and brass options that were the most difficult to do in testing got eliminated for aesthetic reasons.

The last decision to make was regarding the spacing from the top for the various feature rings.  I thought constant spacing of the top and bottom decorative rings might look out of proportion with the different sized bowls.  To my surprise after doing some drawings the bottom inlay at the same height looked fine while the top inlay did not.  In the drawing the bowls on left have the same spacing while the bowls on the right vary by less than a tenth of an inch.  Not much but it does make a difference since it’s the details that count.

Next Up – Sacrificial Bases, Walnut & Cherry Blanks plus Making Veneer

No comments:

Post a Comment